In a bit of unexpected news, the MLB is finding itself in a bit of a cleat controversy. Ben Zobrist of the Chicago Cubs and Mike Clevinger of the Cleveland Indians were both recipients of warning letters from the league on “uniform regulation” violations for their choice in footwear.

Zobrist took to Instagram with an impassioned plea, arguing that the league should relax its ruling to allow him to wear the all-black cleats of past baseball icons that had inspired him:

 

 

Dear @mlb, I still like you but this is rediculous. For the last two years, I have worn black spikes exclusively at Wrigley Field for Day games to pay homage to the history of our great game, and now I am being told I will be fined and disciplined if I continue to wear them. When I was a kid, I was inspired by highlights of the greats such as Ernie Banks and Stan Musial in the 1950s-60s and was captured by the old uniforms and all black cleats with flaps. @newbalancebaseball made a kid’s dream come true by making some all black spikes with the special tongue as well as the “Benny the Jet” @pf_flyers cleats. I am curious as to why @mlb is spending time and money enforcing this now when they haven’t done it previously in the last year and beyond. I have heard nothing but compliments from fans that enjoy the “old school” look. Maybe there is some kid out there that will be inspired to look more into the history of the game by the “flexibility” that I prefer in the color of my shoes. Sincerely, Ben Zobrist

A post shared by Ben Zobrist (@benzobrist18) on

Meanwhile, Clevinger’s violation was a bit more light-hearted in nature. The pitcher was warned for wearing floral-patterned cleats for Mother’s Day:

As you can see in the letters, there’s a lot of rulebook-citing, and even in Zobrist’s case, a referral to the players’ union to make a formal request for negotiating less strigent uniform regulations. It’s... a lot.

We’re talking about cleats! Let baseball players have some fun with their footwear. Much like many of baseball’s unspoken rules, the formal uniform regulations that the MLB keeps pointing to seems pretty needlessly constrictive in this case. If a player wants to pay homage to past icons or express themselves through their cleats, we simply don’t see the harm.

The fun police are really out here.